When I attended a one-room rural school in the 1940s and 1950s, our big fall event was a pie supper.
The name was misleading, a holdover from the days when girls and young women baked pies and brought them to sell—anonymously—at an auction. Boys and young men bid on the pie baked by the apple of their eye. Before that, I’ve heard, young women brought full meals—a picnic supper—for the auction. That reflected the old saying of the way to a man’s heart being through his stomach—and the lack of opportunity for courting.
Each of the girls in my school, including the first graders, brought a box of candy purchased in town. Girls outnumbered boys, so often our fathers or grandparents ended up buying the boxes and we simply took them home.
The real excitement for the kids came from the program we prepared for the jammed schoolhouse. We rehearsed for it for a long time, probably a couple of weeks. The day of the pie supper we pushed the teacher’s desk to one side, put curtains onto wires strung across the front of the school, and created a stage. We recited poems, sang songs (solos, duets, the whole school), played piano and violin uke solos, performed a short play, and played a song or two as a rhythm band. The musicians —every kid in school—played percussion instruments, including a drum, a triangle, several sets of sticks, and sandpaper blocks. We made the latter, covering small blocks of wood with sandpaper and playing them by brushing them together in an up-and-down motion. The teacher played the piano, or sometimes we provided the melody with kazoos or a black plastic one-octave flute called a Tonette. The violin uke fell apart long ago, but I still have my Tonette.
The pie supper served as a fundraiser, so in addition to auctioning off the boxes of candy, we always had a cakewalk. The mothers and other women in the community baked the cakes (from scratch, of course) for this event. We wrote numbers on pieces of paper and taped them in a circle on the “stage.” Anyone who wanted to take part paid a fee (a dime?) and stepped onto a number. The teacher or a student played the piano as the people stepped from number to number. When the music stopped, someone drew a number from a hat. The person standing on that number won a cake.
The whole community came to the pie suppers. The kids were the stars, or thought they were, but everyone had a great time.
—Carolyn Mulford